|
|
Probably
the most celebrated American lawyer of the 20th century, Clarence
Darrow worked as defense counsel in many widely publicized trials.
He was notable as a defender of the underdog and civil rights. He
was an distinguished speaker on agnosticism, liberalism, freethought
and humanism.
Clarence
Darrow was born on April 18, 1857, near Kinsman, Ohio. He attended
Allegheny College and the University of Michigan briefly before
being admitted to the Ohio bar in 1878 at the age of 21. In 1887
he moved to Chicago, where he soon was appointed city corporation
counsel and later the general attorney for the Chicago and Northwestern
Railroad. He resigned this position in 1895 to defend Eugene V.
Debs, president of the American Railway Union, and other union leaders
who had been arrested on a federal charge of contempt of court over
difficulties arising out of the Pullman strike of 1894. Through
this trial Darrow established a national reputation as a labor and
criminal lawyer.
In
1902 President Theodore Roosevelt appointed him an arbitrator in
the Pennsylvania anthracite coal strike. In 1907 he secured the
acquittal of labor organizer William D. "Big Bill" Haywood for the
murder of former Idaho governor Frank Steunenberg. After World War
I he defended war protesters charged with violating state sedition
laws.
The
two most famous trials in which he participated took place in the
1920s. The first of these trials was the notorious Leopold-Loeb
murder case of 1924. He saved Nathan
Leopold and Richard Loeb from execution--but not from prison--for
the murder of 14-year-old Robert Franks. In July 1925 Darrow defended
high school teacher John T. Scopes, who was charged with violating
Tennessee law by teaching evolution. The prosecuting attorney in
this famous "monkey trial" was William Jennings Bryan. Bryan died
a few days after the trial.
In
his writings and speeches Darrow promoted freedom of expression
and the closed shop for unions. He opposed capital punishment and
Prohibition. Once, when asked his attitude toward religion, Darrow
replied: "I feel as I always have, that the earth is the home
and the only home of man, and I am convinced that whatever he is
to get out of his existence he must get while he is here." At
another time, Darrow said: "I am an Agnostic because I am not
afraid to think. I am not afraid of any god in the universe who
would send me or any other man or woman to hell. If there were such
a being, he would not be a god; he would be a devil."
He
gained notoriety for moving, 11 hour closing arguments presented
without notes. He made his cases important by tying the fate of
one lonely persecuted outcast into the entire notion of America
and humanity and freedom - that we might challenge our fears and
actually try to live the dreams of equality by realizing that we
are all brothers.
It
is interesting to note that many of the sources lauding Mr. Darrow
and his legal prowness do not make mention of the Eastland criminal
trial, in which he successfully defended Joseph M. Erickson, chief
engineer. While it is unfair to levy the full responsibility for
the disaster on Erickson's shoulders, certainly gross negligence
and mismanagement occurred, and Darrow's skills were used to secure
a certain travesty of justice.
His
fame did not decline over the years: in the 1970s his life was the
subject of a one-man stage production starring Henry Fonda. He died
in Chicago on March 13, 1938.
Further Reading

An
Eye for An Eye by Clarence Darrow
Attorney for the Damned: Clarence Darrow in the Courtroom
edited by Arthur Weinberg, Chicago, Illinois, The University of
Chicago Press: 1989
Farmington by Clarence Darrow
Resist No Evil by Clarence Darrow
The Story of My Life by Clarence Darrow
A Hero in Spite of Himself by Robert M. Crunden
Clarence Darrow by Arthur and Lila Weinburg
Clarence Darrow for the Defense by Irving Stone, New York,
New York, Doubleday & Company, Inc.: 1975
Clarence Darrow: A One-Man Play by David W. Rintels, Garden
City, New York, Doubleday & Company, Inc.: 1975
Darrow: A Biography by Kevin Tierney, New York, New York,
Thomas Y. Crowell Publishers: 1979
I Confess by Bengamin Gitlow
The People v. Clarence Darrow by Geoffrey Cowan
Here
are some of his cases featured in Attorney for the Damned: Clarence
Darrow in the Courtroom:
1898
THE KIDD CASE, OSHKOSH, WISCONSIN: Kidd, a union organizer,
is charged with conspiracy, growing out of a strike in the large
sash-and-door factory in Oshkosh.
1903 ANTHRACITE MINERS, SCRANTON AND PHILADELPHIA, PENNSYLVANIA:
Darrow represents the United Mine Workers' union before President
Theodore Roosevelt's Anthracite Miner's Convention, investigating
conditions in the mines.
1907 STEVE ADAMS, WALLACE, IDAHO; HAYWOOD, MOYER, AND PETTIBONE,
BOISE, IDAHO: Haywood, first of three union leaders tried for
the murder of ex-Governor Steunenberg.
1912 DARROW IN HIS OWN DEFENSE, LOS ANGELES: Darrow is indicted
and tried for attempted bribe of a juror in the McNamara case.
1924 DEBATE, NEW YORK: Darrow debates Judge Talley who challenged
Darrow's views on crimes and capitol punishment.
1924 LEOPOLD AND LOEB, CHICAGO: Teen-age sons of two millionaires
attempt the perfect crime: kidnapping and murder. They killed 14-year-old
neighbor Bobby Franks for intellectual sport - Darrow worked to
save them from the death penalty as they received life in prison
1925 THE SCOPES EVOLUTION CASE, DAYTON, TENNESSEE: Darrow
meets William Jennings Bryan in the famous "Scopes-Monkey Trial",
defending John Scopes.
1926 THE SWEET CASE, DETROIT: A white mob in Detroit attempted
to drive a black family out of the home they had purchased in a
white neighborhood. In the struggle, a white man was killed, and
the eleven blacks in the house were arrested and charged with murder.
Dr. Henry Sweet was brought to trial and after an initial deadlock,
Darrow argued to the all-white jury: "I insist that there is
nothing but prejudice in this case; that if it was reversed and
eleven white men had shot and killed a black while protecting their
home and their lives against a mob of blacks, nobody would have
dreamed of having them indicted. They would have been given medals
instead..." They were found not guilty.
1932 THE MASSIE CASE, HONOLULU: A strange and puzzling case,
a study of psychology; kidnapping and murder because of honor.
|


|